Should Car Safety Features Have A Paywall?
Safety shouldn't be a subscription says nonprofit Consumer Reports. Plus: 75% of Californians support right to repair ahead of new bill's introduction.
Driving is dangerous. Over 42,000 people died in motor vehicle traffic crashes in the U.S. in 2022—but that isn’t a surprise given 90% of households own at least one car.
Fortunately cars are getting safer. “Automatic Crash Notifications” (ACN) are one such example of new technologies reducing the number of deaths in car collisions each year. Instead of waiting for someone to call 911, ACN’s use sensors in cars to instantly alert first responders when a crash happens, getting medical assistance to passengers as fast as possible. Research has shown that ACN’s reduce fatalities in traffic accidents, and now more advanced notification systems are expected to be even more effective.
You would think a feature this important to safety would be as standard as seat belts. But instead, companies often have ACN’s as a paid feature in addition to the purchase of a vehicle. Nonprofit organization Consumer Reports is looking to change that by putting car companies on blast for making safety a subscription. Their new campaign is calling for companies to make ACN’s a standard feature — which only Hyundai has done to date.
SaaS: Safety as a Service
Putting computers in cars has no doubt created countless benefits for drivers with features like ACN’s, but there are other consequences of connecting cars to the internet. Because of their connectivity, internet-enabled cars are tethered to their manufacturers which allows almost any feature to turn into a subscription.
Take Apple, which came out with an “Emergency SOS” safety feature in 2022 which uses satellite technology to allow users to send information in an emergency even without cellular and Wi-Fi coverage. There’s one catch: you need to start paying for it after two years of owning your phone.
Maybe Apple is passing along the high costs associated with these satellites to the users who want to feel more secure. Or maybe it's yet another tactic to get people to upgrade their phones since the feature goes away after two years. Regardless, the bottom line is that a potentially life-saving feature will have a continuous price tag rather than being baked into the cost of the phone.
Internet-connected devices, whether phones or cars, have allowed manufacturers to maintain an unprecedented amount of control over products long after they leave the factory. And while internet connected cars absolutely are in need of software updates for safety and cybersecurity reasons, these same software controls can be used in extractive ways.
There are comical examples where companies are putting paywalls on less important car features from heated seats to special software-controlled sport-modes. But they aren’t always funny, more flagrant examples include Ford’s recent patent application for a self-impounding car—and now life-saving ACN’s.
Cut the Cord on Strings-Attached Ownership
Companies will need to be forced to make changes to this model of strings-attached ownership of cars. After all, these subscriptions can be lucrative and aren’t confined to safety features.
Many consumer advocates point to government intervention to correct this problem, but there seems to be mixed feelings from regulators and governments on what to do about this asymmetrical power between companies and consumers.
The good news is that some regulators are stepping up. Regulators like the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) are taking on companies with lawsuits and formal complaints against companies like Tesla and John Deere. Tesla has been known to use the internet connectivity of their cars to put up software locks, keeping users from accessing car features. Deere on the other hand is notorious for using software to force farmers into paying for Deere-authorized repair services.
The bad news is that other regulators are not on the same page. Take the recent guidance from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) telling automakers not to comply with a law requiring they share key data for car repairs, which would allow car companies to withhold vehicle data from users and keep drivers stuck paying for their authorized repair services.
It’s clear that changing this strings-attached model of ownership won’t happen on its own. But the high stakes of safety features, like Automatic Crash Notifications (ACN) show the extreme amount of control that carmakers have over internet-connected vehicles. Safety should be standard, and Consumer Report’s campaign should be a wake-up call for governments to take action to prioritize the safety of drivers.
More from Fight to Repair
Other News
75% of Californians support right to repair and a bill is making progress through committees—receiving broad support from both political parties. It has gained endorsements from the Los Angeles Times, local officials, repair shops, and environmental groups. The proposed California Right to Repair Act would be the strongest law of its kind, requiring manufacturers to provide access to repair materials for several years says Kevin O’Reilly at U.S. PIRG.
Google’s Pixel Fold catches average repair reviews. Despite some challenges such as the USB C port being attached to the motherboard, making replacement difficult but not impossible, the Pixel Fold received an overall favorable review score. The device received a repairability score of 6.5 out of 10 from Droid Life and due to factors like the battery being less accessible and the labor-intensive repair process.
Consumers still intend to purchase gadgets despite higher prices according to a new study from TechRadar, with only 18-24% of respondents planning to delay or cancel tech purchases. Somewhat contradictory however, 40 percent of respondents indicated they will spend less on electronics in the near future.
The fashion industry is preparing for new regulations aimed at reducing carbon emissions and waste, with the European Union (EU) implementing rules on supply chains, greenwashing, and sustainable design. However, there are concerns about the industry's ability to break with its current environmental impact, human rights abuses, and the short lifespan of clothing before disposal.
The EU’s newly proposed Right to Repair Directive aims to reduce premature disposal of defective goods by promoting repair over replacement. Manufacturers will be required to fix goods that are deemed repairable under EU law and must provide clear information to consumers about their repair obligations. Member states will need to establish online repair platforms and incorporate the directive into their national laws within 24 months of its codification.
Recycling graphite waste and utilizing wine and grape pomace for coloring wood comes from company Listone Giordano is showcasing two flooring products promoting sustainable including . The project aims to transform how wood products are made while adhering to the principles of the circular economy and sustainability.
There are now over 2,500 Repair Cafés worldwide, gaining particular momentum in the United States as a way to combat the throwaway culture by providing free meeting places where volunteers help repair items and offer instruction.
A new bottle bill in Massachusetts would increase the deposit from a nickel to a dime and expand to more beverage containers, with the aim of improving recycling rates and reducing litter and waste. Advocates argue that bottle deposits are an effective recycling tool and updating the law is necessary to align with other states and reduce costs associated with disposal and clean up.
A new book, "To Dye For: How Toxic Fashion Is Making Us Sick" exposes the public health risks associated with chemically-treated fabrics and synthetic fibers in the fast fashion industry, highlighting the presence of carcinogenic and endocrine-disrupting substances. Author Alden Wicker calls for greater regulation, ingredient labeling, and a crackdown on greenwashing, aiming to protect consumers from the harmful effects of toxic chemicals in clothing.
The continued dominance of private cars is being highlighted amidst new announcements of Toyota's new solid-state battery for electric vehicles (EV’s). While this is seen as progress, it raises concerns about the need to prioritize mass transportation and rethink urban planning to tackle congestion and road accidents, reduce emissions, and live within the world's material constraints. The Guardian’s editorial board says the future of mobility must extend beyond individual vehicles, and the focus should be on a holistic approach to transportation that includes public transport.